A few weeks back, I dropped Google search in favor of DuckDuckGo, an alternative search engine that does not log your searches. Today, I’m here to report on that experience and suggest two even better secure search tools: StartPage and Ixquick.
The probelm with DuckDuckGo
As I outlined in my initial blog post, DuckDuckGo falls down probably as a consequence of its emphasis on privacy. Whereas Google results are based on an array of personal variables that tie specific result sets to your social graph…a complex web of data points collected on you through your Chrome Browser, Android apps, browser cookies, location data, possibly even the contents of your documents and emails stored on Google’s servers (that’s a guess, but totally within the scope of reason). This is a considerable handicap for DuckDuckGo.
But moreover, Google’s algorithm remains superior to everything else out there.
The benefits of using DuckDuckGo, of course, are that you are far more anonymous, especially if you are searching in private browser mode, accessing the Internet through a VPN or Tor, etc.
Again, given the explosive revelations about aggressive NSA data collection and even of government programs that hack such social graphs, and the potential leaking of that data to even worse parties, many people may decide that, on balance, they are better off dealing with poor search precision rather than setting themselves up for a cataclysmic breach of their data.
I’m one such person, but to be quite honest, I was constantly turning back to Google because DuckDuckGo just wouldn’t get me what I knew was out there.
Fortunately, I found something better: StartPage and Ixquick.
Google but without all the evil
There are two important things to understand about StartPage and Ixquick:
- Both StartPage and Ixquick use proxy services to query other search engines. In the case of Ixquick, they query multiple search engines and then return the results with the highest average rank. StartPage only queries Google, but via the proxy service, making your search private and free of the data mining intrigue that plagues the major search engines.
Still some shortcomings remain
But, like DuckDuckGo, neither Ixquick or StartPage are able to source your social graph, so they will never get results as closely tailored to you as Google. By design, they are not looking at your cookies or building their own database of you, so they won’t be able to guess your location or political views, and therefore, will never skew results around those variables. Then again, your results will be more broadly relevant and serendipitous, saving you from the personal echo-chamber that you may have found in Google.
It’s been over a month since I switched from DuckDuckGo to StartPage and so far it’s been quite good. StartPage even has a passable image and video search. I almost never go to Google anymore. In fact, I’ve used a browser plugin called Stylish to re-skin Google’s search interface with the NSA logo just as a humorous reminder that every search is being collected by multiple parties.
For that matter, I’ve used the same plugin to re-skin StartPage since where they get high marks for privacy and search results, they’re interface design needs major work…but I’m just picky that way.
So, with my current setup, I’ve got StartPage as my default browser, set in my omnibar in Firefox. Works like a charm!